nothing to do with ducks?... it does. Are any of you members of Delta Waterfowl? Predator trapping is a large part of their program and research. About 75% of the hunted ducks in NA comes from the prairie pothole region of NA. Without the trapping of furbearers the success rate of a hen to raise a brood drops off substantially. You ask Phil if he leaves his cripple ducks for a day or kills them immediately. I can honestly say I make an effort to kill cripples as fast as I can. However there are times that a cripple gets away, or flys half a mile and lands crippled unable to fly again. That duck will suffer far longer than a coon, beaver, fox, ermine or other furbearer would in a trap. I would give trappers the benefit of due diligence more often than I would most hunters. Hunting and trapping are not apples and oranges they are tangerines and oranges and many times tangelos. You say to ask a vet if that otter suffered. Well how about asking a vet about a hunting dog that has steped in a badger hole and tears an ACL or a hunting dog that finds a barbwire fence. Should that hunter quit hunting because the dog had to suffer? Don’t justify being against trapping because of bycatch. I don’t favor the end of recreational fishing because an out of season fish may be caught and die or suffer because it was foul hooked.
I enjoy being outside. I like hunting, fishing, and have taken up part time trapping over the last year. What I do, could be called trapping for sport or recreational trapping. I don’t make a living off of it, heck I am way more in the red than I thought it would be. But just because fur bearers are one of the few game creatures that can be harvested and sold of cash money does not mean if you can’t do so for a living it is not justifiable. I am sure there are plenty of people on here who have hunting lease or have even bought land or a place to stay for hunting in another state.
What I am trying to say is hunting fishing and trapping are not apples, oranges and cherries they are oranges, lemons and tangerines that are grafted and all grow from the same tree. The similarities far out number the differences. I am not saying everyone should take up trapping or other kinds of hunting or deep sea fishing but it does an individual, no good to discredit the other and say they are not comparable and thus not worth defending.